PCB Assembly Graphic

How to Evaluate and Test the Functionality of a Plastic Prototype

Tensile (tension) test of the polyethylene. The most common type of test used to measure the mechanical properties of a material is the tension test.

Rapid prototype plastic injection molding is a powerful tool for product development, offering a fast and affordable way to create new plastic products. However, the work doesn’t end once the prototype is made. Testing is necessary to ensure that the prototype performs as expected. Without proper testing, even the most innovative designs could face challenges in production or in real-world use, leading to wasted resources or market failure. In this article, we’ll dive into the importance of testing plastic prototypes and outline the essential steps involved in the process.

What is Rapid Prototype Injection Molding?

Rapid prototype injection molding is a manufacturing process that allows for the quick creation of plastic prototypes. The goal is to develop functional models that closely resemble the final product, manufactured in the same way and with the same materials that will ultimately be used, so designers and engineers can test their components before committing to large-scale production.

The process involves the following steps:

  • Injection of Molten Plastic: Molten plastic is injected into each cavity of the mold.
  • Cooling and Solidification: The plastic cools and hardens into the desired shape.
  • Ejection of the Prototype: After cooling, the mold opens, and the prototype is ejected, ready for inspection.

What makes this process “rapid” is the use of aluminum molds instead of stainless steel molds, and any part feature that can’t be created by the core and cavity is formed with manually loaded core pins or pick outs. Aluminum molds are also more cost-effective than steel molds, making them ideal for smaller production runs and faster prototyping.

Benefits of Rapid Prototype Injection Molding

One of the primary reasons companies choose rapid prototype injection molding is the speed and cost-effectiveness. Prototypes can be created in a matter of days to weeks, depending on complexity, allowing teams to quickly move through the development process.

Key benefits include:

  • Quick Turnaround: Prototypes can be made in just a few days, allowing design teams to quickly test and refine their concepts.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: This method works well for small production runs, typically ranging from 50 to 10,000 parts, helping companies test ideas before committing to full-scale production.
  • Material Flexibility: Rapid prototyping supports all materials that can be injection molded, usch as ABS, polypropylene and rubber-like TPEs, ensuring the prototype mirrors the final product’s characteristics.
  • High-Quality Results: Prototypes created through this method mimic the final product in both appearance and functionality, enabling more accurate real-world testing.

While aluminum molds have several advantages, they do come with some limitations. They aren’t as durable as steel molds and may not be ideal for high-volume production or for large, complex parts.

Why Testing Plastic Prototypes Matters

Testing is a necessary step in the prototyping process because it confirms whether the design works as intended. It ensures that the prototype meets both functional and safety standards before moving forward with production.

Testing helps you:

  • Validate the Design: Testing shows if the prototype performs as expected and meets design criteria. It highlights any issues that might require adjustments.
  • Identify Issues Early: Early testing helps catch potential problems before they become expensive to fix during mass production.
  • Ensure Compliance: Many products need to meet industry-specific standards, and testing ensures that the prototype meets these regulations. Prototype injection molded parts can be used for verification and validation activities.
  • Save Costs: Detecting defects early in the design phase can prevent costly production runs or post-launch recalls.

Testing isn’t just about confirming that the design works; it’s about ensuring that the product is safe, durable, and ready for mass production.

Preparing for Prototype Testing

To test a prototype effectively, it’s important to have a clear plan in place. Define the goals and determine the methods that will be used to evaluate the prototype.

Here are some key steps to ensure smooth testing:

  • Set Clear Testing Goals: Define specific objectives, such as testing whether a container can survive a 3-foot drop without cracking.
  • Identify Key Testing Criteria: Focus on the most important aspects of the prototype’s performance, such as:
    • Dimensions: Ensure parts match the required tolerances.
    • Appearance: Evaluate visual qualities like color, texture, and finish.
    • Strength: Test how the prototype holds up under expected (and unexpected) use scenarios and forces.
    • Moldability: Check for defects like sink marks, incomplete fill of thin areas, or flow line issues.
  • Plan for Adjustments: Be ready to make changes based on feedback from testing, and retest as needed.

Key Areas of Testing for Plastic Prototypes

With the plan in place, the prototype should be tested in several key areas. Testing these elements will help assess the product’s functionality, strength, and durability.

Dimensional Accuracy

  • Coordinate Measuring Machines (CMMs): These machines provide precise 3D measurements.
  • 3D Scanners: These create a digital model of the prototype for direct comparison with the design.
  • Go/No-Go Gauges: Simple tools that help check if the prototype meets dimensional requirements.

Material Properties

  • Tensile Strength: Measures how resistant the material is to stretching or breaking.
  • Impact Resistance: Tests how the prototype holds up to sudden impacts.
  • Heat Deflection: Evaluates the material’s ability to withstand heat-induced deformation.

Visual and Tactile Inspection

  • Sink Marks: Depressions on the surface caused by uneven cooling.
  • Warpage: Bending or twisting of the prototype as it cools.
  • Flow Lines: Marks where plastic flows into the mold.
  • Flash: Excess material at the edges of the part.

Functional Testing

  • Assembly Testing: Ensures parts fit together as intended.
  • Fit Testing: Checks snap-fits or press-fits commonly used in plastic assembly.
  • Durability Testing: Simulates real-world use to assess long-term performance.
  • Environmental Testing: Exposes the prototype to extreme conditions like heat, cold, moisture, or UV light.

Adapting Designs Based on Test Results

Once testing is complete, review the results and make the necessary design changes, such as:

  • Modifying the Prototype’s Shape: To improve functionality.
  • Refining the Gating System: To optimize the flow of plastic in the mold.
  • Adjusting Wall Thickness: To improve strength or reduce material usage.
  • Changing Surface Texture: To enhance functionality or appearance.

These adjustments ensure that the prototype is functional, efficient, and cost-effective.

Advanced Testing for Complex Parts

For more advanced prototypes, additional testing techniques may be required, such as:

  • X-ray and CT Scanning: To examine the internal structure without damaging the prototype.
  • Computer Simulations: Software that models real-world behavior and identifies potential issues before they arise.

Compliance with Industry Standards

Many products need to meet regulatory standards before they can be produced. Common certifications include:

  • FDA Testing: For products that interact with food, drugs, or medical devices.
  • UL Testing: Ensures safety for electrical components.
  • ASTM or ISO Standards: These are applied to many product types to ensure safety and performance.

Ensuring compliance with these standards early on helps prevent delays and complications later in the process.

From Prototype to Production

Once testing is complete and the prototype is validated, it’s time to move toward full-scale production. This involves:

  • Design Verification: Ensuring the design can be scaled for mass production.
  • Tooling Adjustments: Making any necessary changes to production tools.
  • Pilot Production Runs: Small-scale runs that confirm the design can be produced at full capacity.

Partner with Protoshop for Your Plastic Product Needs

Rapid prototype injection molding, paired with thorough testing, helps companies move from concept to market more efficiently. At Protoshop, we offer prototype mold fabrication and molding services, providing high-quality prototype parts for faster product development activities. Ready to bring your idea to life? Contact Protoshop today to get started.

Excellent
Based on 7 reviews
Dana Taylor
Dana Taylor
2024-01-17
If you're in need of a molding prototype shop, Dylann and Jimmy at Protoshop are sure to not only meet but exceed your expectations. Their team demonstrates remarkable responsiveness and proactiveness, contributing to an exceptionally efficient overall process. The speed at which they deliver top-notch work is truly impressive. Protoshop's commitment to customer satisfaction is apparent in their flexibility and willingness to closely collaborate with clients to address specific needs. An exemplary instance of this was their accommodation of our request to have our customer onsite for part evaluation and mold changes while we were present. What sets Protoshop apart is not solely their technical proficiency but also their dedication to providing valuable insights and design advice. Their expertise extends beyond standard projects, showcasing proficiency in handling complex components for diverse applications, be it over-molded sealing parts or flexible components. In conclusion, if you're on the lookout for a reliable and efficient partner for your manufacturing and molding requirements, I wholeheartedly recommend Protoshop. Their combination of expertise, responsiveness, and commitment to customer satisfaction makes them an exceptional choice for a variety of projects.
Brittany Mason
Brittany Mason
2023-06-06
I have worked with Photoshop on several mold designs over the past year. From the moment I reached out to them with an inquiry, they were prompt in their communication and eager to assist me. I have greatly appreciated and benefited from their extensive expertise and prompt feedback. They consistently offering valuable suggestions and insights that ultimately saved us money in the overall design. As for the quality of work they provided, Dylann and her team have always come through. If any issues do arise, they have been quick to offer solutions and kept us up to date throughout the whole process. If you're looking for a reliable partner for your plastics molding needs, I would check them out.
Stacie Depner
Stacie Depner
2022-10-18
Having worked with Dylann and Jimmy prior to Protoshop, I knew the immense level of expertise they have for this business and it proved to carry through. They are honest straight shooters that will help guide you and find the best solution for your molds. We needed a mild that could be versatile and allow us to easily change out one side of the design. Dylann helped us come up with an approach that will allow us to continuously iteration the design without having to make a whole new mold every time.
Chad Follmar
Chad Follmar
2022-08-23
Dylann and team are wonderful to work with. On multiple programs, they have delivered quality product in a matter of days. The design for moldability support is unparalled to ensure your part is ready to order.
Garrett Garner
Garrett Garner
2022-06-15
We work regularly with Protoshop on a variety of complex components for various projects. They are an excellent company to work with providing a vast history of experience to help their clients optimize designs. We have worked with them on microfluidic chips with small feature sizes, over molded sealing parts and flexible parts. They have experience working with many materials including Topas (COC), polycarbonate, TPE, PE, and PP. I would highly recommend reaching out on your next project. The team is very responsive to design changes as well as delivering to tight timelines. They also offer design advice and best practices which have helped expedite design iterations.
Steven Soeder
Steven Soeder
2022-06-13
Great experience with Protoshop. Dylann is extremely responsive and great to work with. Very fast turn-around. Worked with us on our order to get what we needed. I was able to drop ship 3d printed parts from another vendor to Protoshop to have them match-fit and incorporated into our tooling. I will be back again.
Wendell Woidyla
Wendell Woidyla
2022-05-31
Dylann at Protoshop is excellent to work with: highly responsive and proactive. This is possibly the fastest, high-quality work I have ever witnessed. 1 week...from payment (start) to delivery (after CTQ measurements at Protoshop), we had 100 test samples of a component we intend to use in high volume manufacturing. Thank you for the tremendous work! I would highly recommend Protoshop, and will plan to use Protoshop services in the future.